Basically it seems that Thunderbird only remembers/savesfor the first/default identity account. It is very annoying when the signature gets placed at the bottom and another huge oversight on Mozilla's part.
Fortunately you can hack/manually set this setting.
Click Tools -> Options -> Advanced -> Config Editor
Then search for ".sig_bottom" and set them all to false, and your problem will finally be solved.
thunderbird, defaults, quotebasically, savesfor, default, oversight, mozilla, fortunately, hack, manually, fixing, advanced, config, quot, sig_bottom,